Inductees: [Bold print indicates player still active in league]
1977 - Bill Crossetta
1977 - Jim Hargraves
1977 - Tom Marcinak
1977 - Bill Nydam
1977 - Ed Paffendorf
1977 - Frank Sharp
1978 - Douglas Boyd
1978 - Henry Eggleston
1978 - Ed Mooney
1978 - Edward Paffendorf Sr.
1978 - Louis Rotundo
1979 - Angelo Janotti
1979 - Stan Tompkins
1980 - Lawrence Benton
1980 - Benjamin Ward
1981 - Henry Bellerson
1981 - Arthur Murray
1982 - Walter Tompkins
1984 - John Genter
1984 - James Peluso
1985 - Franklin Benedict
1985 - Dick Coleman
1985 - Johnny Rotundo
1985 - Harry Sauer Sr.
1986 - Francis Coleman
1986 - Vito DiCesare Sr.
1987 - Paul Faurie
1987 - Charles Homan
1988 - Howard Johnstone
1988 - Gordon Serviss
1988 - Bill Stvrtecki
1989 - Stephen Case
1989 - Vito DiCesare Jr.
1990 - John Homan
1990 - Alonzo Stevens
1991 - Vincent DiDonato
1991 - Tom Flagler
1992 - Thomas Donovan
1992 - Harry Sauer Jr.
1995 - Dan Coleman
1995 - Jim Spencer
1996 - Charles Maslowski
1996 - Robert Ponesse
1997 - John Mitchell
1998 - Chris DiCesare
1998 - John Stegenga
1999 - Don Parrone
1999 - Paul Scagnelli
1999 - Don Torelli
2000 - Mike Pacella
2000 - Mel Tweed
2001 - Stanley Rhodes
2001 - Bill Post Sr.
2001 - John Wilcox
2002 - Dave Garzione
2002 - Donald Ferguson
2003 - Rich Argenio
2003 - Arnold Griffin Jr.
2004 - George Mackey
2004 - Gary Atkins
2004 - Dean Scagnelli
2004 - Jim Nelson
2005 - Butch Coleman
2005 - Rick Sicina
2006 - Jack Decker
2006 - Leroy Marshall
2007 - Tommy DiDonato
2007 - Jim Ruggiero Sr.
2008 - Vincent Gordon
2008 - Patrick Berardinelli Sr.
2009 - James Henry
2009 - Joe Rotunda
2010 - Karl Fred
2010 - Will Ostrander
