KEY: TEAM LISTED FIRST AND IN CAPITAL LETTERS WON SERIES
1945-46 BROADWAY GARAGE vs Balmville Grange at Grace Methodist (No Scores)
1946-47 BROADWAY GARAGE vs Little Britain Grange at Grace 2-3 11-4 6-4
1951-52 TRINITY METHODIST vs Broadway Garage at Odd Fellows 8-1 13-10
1953-54 ASSOCIATED REFORMED vs Trinity Methodist 5-4 8-5
1961-62 MOULTON MEMORIAL vs Balmville Grange 16-0 5-7 8-3
1962-63 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Moulton Memorial at Grace Methodist 3-7 3-2 3-1
1963-64 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Moulton Memorial at Bethlehem 2-1 8-3
1964-65 UNITED PRESBYTERIAN vs Little Britain at LBG 5-6 4-3 17-11
1965-66 ST GEORGE's vs Little Britain at Bethlehem 5-1 12-4
1966-67 ST GEORGE'S winner 2 rounds vs All Stars at LBG 8-3 14-3 4-0
1967-68 ST GEORGE'S winner 2 rounds vs Moulton Memorial at LBG 4-2 7-4 9-8
1968-69 LITTLE BRITAIN vs St George's at Bethlehem 2-9 5-2 5-4
1969-70 ST GEORGE'S vs Little Britain at LBG 5-17 4-3 6-4
1970-71 ST GEORGE.S vs Little Britain at Bethlehem 5-3 5-6 18-7
1971-72 ST GEORGE'S winner 2 rounds vs all stars 7-6 3-5 3-5
1972-73 LITTLE BRITAIN won 3 rounds vs all stars at Bethlehem 6-4 7-0 2-1
1973-74 LITTLE BRITAIN vs St. George's at LBG 0-2 12-4 12-5
1974-75 LITTLE BRITAIN vs St George's at Bethlehem 15-13 6-5
1975-76 BETHLEHEM vs Little Britain at LBG 5-2(10 inn) 4-1
1976-77 LITTLE BRITAIN vs St Francis Crusaders at Bethlehem 4-3 15-0
1977-78 BETHLEM vs Little Britain at Balmville 6-3 4-5 9-1
1978-79 KNIGHTS vs Meadow Hill Guards at LBG 12-4 3-6 5-4
1979-80 KNIGHTS vs Little Britain at Bethlehem 7-3 12-3
1980-81 ST FRANCIS CRUSADERS vs Knights at Balmville 10-9 3-9
1981-82 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Woodcock Auto at LBG 3-1 14-3
1982-83 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Knights at Bethlehem 15-7 8-7
1983-84 MEADOW HILL GUARDS vs Knights at Balmville ( No Scores)
1984-85 KNIGHTS vs Guards at Bethlehem 9-8 6-5
1985-86 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Knights at Balmville 2-1 8-4
1986-87 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Knights at Moose Lodge 11-9 2-5 11-7
1987-88 BETHLEHEM vs Knights at LBG (No Scores)
1988-89 ST FRANCIS CRUSADERS vs Bethlehem at Balmville 5-7 10-8 9-5
1989-90 ST FRANCIS CRUSADERS vs Balmville at Bethlehem 7-15 7-2 5-0
1990-91 GUARDS vs St Francis Crusaders at Moose Lodge 10-6 2-4 10-1
1991-92 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Knights at LBG 3-13 8-6 4-1
1992-93 GUARDS vs Knights at Balmville (No Scores)
1993-94 ST FRANCIS CRUSADERS vs Sargent Warriors at Bethlehem 5-4 10-3
1994-95 GUARDS vs Moose Lodge ( where?) no scores
1995-96 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Bethlehem at Bethlehem 10-4 12-9
1996-97 GUARDS vs Sargent Warriors at Balmville 4-0 4-3
1997-98 LITTLE BRITAIN vs Guards at Moose Lodge 6-4 1-9 2-0
1998-99 GARDNERTOWN vs Bethlehem at LBG 4-3 2-8 11-1
1999-00 MEADOW HILL GUARDS vs St Francis Flames at Bethlehem 7-1 4-2
2000-01 ST FRANCIS FLAMES vs Bethlehem at Balmville 9-5 12-6
2001-02 BETHLEHEM vs Meadow Hill Guards at Gardnertown 7-5 4-3
2002-03 MOULTON MEM. vs St Francis Crusaders at Moulton Mem.4-9 4-2 5-3
2003-04 BETHLEHEM vs Little Britain at Bethlehem 3-0 2-4 9-7
2004-05 ST. FRANCIS FLAMES vs Newburgh Rec #2 at Balmville 4-5 4-2 7-1
2005-06 REC-KING CREW vs Meadow Hill Guards at Gardnertown 4-2 8-2
2006-07 REC-KING CREW vs Bethlehem Warriors at Moulton Mem 9-6 10-8
2007-08 LITTLE BRITAIN vs. Bethlehem at Bethlehem 10-7 10-3
2008-09 BALMVILLE-LATTINGTOWN vs. Marlboro at Moulton Memorial 4-0 8-12
2009-10 REC-KING CREW vs. Balmville-Lattingtown at Moulton Memorial 6-4, 15-0
